The CBAM formula is simple: embedded emission intensity times tonnes exported gives the number of certificates to surrender; multiply by the certificate price and subtract any carbon price already paid at origin. The hard part is that each of the four variables has a range, and different choices can move the result by a factor of two or more.
Start with emission intensity. Primary aluminium emits from two sources: direct emissions from anode consumption and anode effects, and indirect emissions from the electricity used in electrolysis. Aluminium is one of the few CBAM sectors where indirect emissions count, so the power source dominates. A coal-powered smelter can exceed 10 tonnes of CO₂-equivalent per tonne of aluminium in indirect emissions alone; a hydro-powered one is close to zero.
Next, default values. Without measured data, a declaration has to use the EU’s published defaults, which are set with reference to higher-emitting production routes. On an illustrative basis, a plant with relatively clean power might declare roughly half the default intensity when using measured data. For an exporter shipping ten thousand tonnes a year, that gap translates into certificate costs in the order of millions of euros.
The third variable is the certificate price, which follows the weekly average of EU ETS auctions. Running a sensitivity across the 60 to 90 euro range seen in recent years, every 10-euro move shifts that exporter’s annual cost by hundreds of thousands of euros. Companies cannot control the price, but they can control the multiplier: their intensity.
The fourth is the deduction for carbon already paid. Where the plant sits in a carbon market and has actually paid, that amount can be deducted. The deduction needs proof: allowance surrender records, the price basis, and a description of coverage. Without the documents it exists only on paper.
Put the four variables in one table and the to-do list writes itself: build measured data to replace defaults; organise the contracts and certificates that prove the power source; keep complete records of carbon prices paid. None of these is a one-off. They depend on monthly data accumulated on a consistent basis.
A note on the numbers: everything above is illustrative, meant to show how the variables interact, not any company’s actual data. A real calculation uses the plant’s own metering and the certificate price for the period.